It is with profound sadness that we mark the passing of Margo Donohue, a spirited podcaster, storyteller, and author whose vibrant presence left a lasting mark on the worlds of books, movies, and creativity. Margo was best known as the host of two beloved podcasts: Book vs. Movie and What a Creep Podcast.
Her vivid curiosity and bold perspective turned each episode into a welcoming space for engaging conversation. With a passion for storytelling—and an infectious laugh—she offered audiences sharp insights and thoughtful critiques, cleverly bridging literature and visual media.
Originally from Glen Cove, New York, Margo made her home in Brooklyn, a place that fueled both her identity and her writing. Her pride in her borough found expression not only in her podcasts but also in her debut book, “Filmed in Brooklyn.” In it, she wove together her love for cinema and her home borough in a work that resonated with fellow Brooklynites and film lovers alike.
Following the success of her first book, Margo expanded her literary contributions with “Fever: The Complete History of Saturday Night Fever,” which was eagerly anticipated and slated for publication on August 26. Her next project, already in the works, was a deep dive into the cultural history and adaptations of Stephen King’s “Carrie.” These works exemplified her wide-ranging intellectual hunger and her ability to transform enthusiasm into meticulous storytelling.
Her dear friend Brandi Koskie paid tribute to Margo’s unique energy and warmth:
“Spirited and fierce, so much joy, so much goodness and kindness… The most contagious laugh. A smile that took up the most real estate a smile can.”
Brandi fondly remembered how Margo acknowledged her (“Tofutti”) in “Filmed in Brooklyn,” an elegiac moment that revealed their cherished bond. She also shared a tender reminder from their last meeting in New York City:
“‘There will be other times,’ she said. But we don’t always get the other times… Say the things, hug the hugs—it’s all too precious and fleeting.”
Margo’s influence extended beyond her podcasts and writing. She was a thoughtful, generous presence in creative communities, often reaching out to say hello, share encouragement, and uplift others through her curiosity and friendship. To her audiences and peers from Fitbloggin’ and literary circles, she was a beacon of authenticity, humor, and human connection.
Those who knew her remember Margo as the perfect blend of intellect and levity—a woman who could analyze the most nuanced plot point but save her boldest joy for silly stories or happy laughter. Even in distance, she was never far: a text, a check-in, a thoughtful message.
Margo Donohue’s sudden departure is a blow to those who had the privilege of knowing her voice. Yet, her laughter, curiosity, and enthusiasm endure in her work—and in every listener who felt uplifted by her presence. Her books, podcasts, and creative legacy remain as invitations to explore, reflect, and laugh a little louder.
To honor her memory is to listen deeply, critique thoughtfully, and connect empathetically—with others and with art. As Brandi eloquently reflected:
“I am so grateful to have called Margo my friend. She was a joy. Rest easy, sweet Margo.”
We carry her legacy forward—not with sorrow alone, but with gratitude for every story she told, every laugh she shared, and every creative spark she ignited.